Oracle executives Dr. Michelle Flemmings and Kurt Hagerman discussed key challenges and opportunities in healthcare during a recent interview. Flemmings emphasized the need for improved payer-provider collaboration and streamlined claims processes, while Hagerman focused on strengthening cybersecurity measures across the industry. Both executives highlighted the potential for new technologies, including artificial intelligence and machine learning, to drive efficiencies and enhance patient care. Looking ahead, they see opportunities for significant disruption in healthcare, including advancements in precision medicine and a shift towards value-based care models.
Watch the interview to learn more.
Stephanie Butler:
Welcome everyone. I'm excited to be here with Kurt Hagerman, who is the Field Chief Information Security Officer at North America Cloud Infrastructure Engineering at Oracle. And also have with us, Dr. Michelle Flemmings, who is the Industry Executive, Healthcare, North America Cloud Infrastructure at Oracle. So welcome to both of you.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Thank you.
Kurt Hagerman:
Thanks.
Stephanie Butler:
So I'm really excited to get the opportunity to chat with both of you today about some of the issues that I think are really important for this industry. So I want to start with an opening question. It's a little more general, which is what do you think is the biggest challenge facing the payer industry today? Want to start?
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Sure. Well, I come to this conversation as a provider to the soul. I've been an ER doc for 30 plus years, an internist before that. I was the original paper doc. What the challenge is, I believe, is that the intersection between payer and provider needs to be tighter. We need to have better flow of information. We need to break down the silos. We need to stop the repetition and the processes around simple things like claims. Get the claim in the first time right so I don't have to leave the patient's bedside again to do it again. And then on the other side, it's clear, it's ready, it can either be paid or it can be contested, and then go from there. Patients get what they need, provider gets what they need, payer potentially saves money.
Stephanie Butler:
Sounds simple, but it's not.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Not at all. No.
Stephanie Butler:
What about you, Kurt? What do you think?
Kurt Hagerman:
Well, I come from the security perspective, and I think that there's still just a lot of challenges in healthcare security overall, whether it's payer or provider. In that their mission isn't security, their mission is patient care. And so the focus oftentimes is not enough on cybersecurity, and we continue to see breaches and ransomware attacks. So I think one of the significant issues facing the entire industry is, how do they up the security game to start being better at defending against these kinds of attacks and preventing people's records from being compromised. A healthcare record is tremendously valuable because it contains a lot of information. It's personal information, it's financial information, it's insurance information, and that can all be used by the threat actors to perpetrate all kinds of fraud. From fake tax returns to medical insurance fraud to payday loans. Everything.
Stephanie Butler:
It's scary.
Kurt Hagerman:
It's very scary.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
And what I will ask though is, in doing so... Because you're absolutely right. Every time I get one of those envelopes and it says, "We've now given you an Experian account..." I think I have one in perpetuity. I think I will die and I will still have accounts open. There have been so many. And that's just me. But speaking from that provider perspective and as the perspective of a patient, absolutely I want the respect given to the cybersecurity, because I think without that, you don't deserve my trust. You really don't. I think we're eroding the trust of the patient also by not getting this right. From the provider perspective, please, yes, we need to do it, but also don't make it be that now I have to go and get multiple log-ons or I have to get, God forbid, something like a retinal scan and a bunch of fingerprints in order just to get to the data. So it has to be a happy medium.
Stephanie Butler:
I want to follow up a little bit on that with Kurt about the security. Because what do you think are the most common security issues that are facing payers today?
Kurt Hagerman:
I think it's really the cybersecurity basics. It's strong authentication. They have so much data and a lot of times they're using older legacy systems that were built to only have a username and password as the way that they are allowed to get into them. Some of them don't even have the capability of adding multi-factor authentication. And so time after time, these ransomware attacks and other breaches are caused through compromised credentials. So one of the best ways to prevent that is through strong multi-factor authentication. So instead of it just being a username and password, it's something else. And it's getting easier now with the phone technology and even Windows Hello, now it's just when I log into my laptop in the morning, the camera comes on, scans my face and says, "Log in." I don't have to put in anything. A lot of companies are moving to passwordless authentication, which is using easy biometrics. In the healthcare setting, there are even RFID type devices that will help log people in because you are issued a badge, the badge is verified that that's you, and so they can be used to more easily log in.
To Michelle's point earlier, you have to increase the security, but you can't at the same time increase the difficulty-
Stephanie Butler:
Right. I was just thinking that.
Kurt Hagerman:
... of getting at the data. Two other things that I see a lot is, just a lack of patching of systems. These healthcare payers have expansive systems, whether they're on-prem or even in the cloud, and that's the second biggest avenue for breach is unpatched systems. It's not that difficult to do, but it's kind of boring. It's not the sexy, "Hey, we got the next gen firewall, or we've got these other new cybersecurity toys." And so paying attention to good, strong vulnerability management, good strong authentication management, and then finally encrypting your data, so that if someone does get in and take it, it's not useful to them. Those are some of the things that I think those are three very basic things that organizations can adopt that would reduce their risk by a huge amount.
Stephanie Butler:
Yeah, they're fundamentals.
Kurt Hagerman:
Yeah, it's basic blocking and tackling.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Also before we started, you were talking before we walked in with Stephanie, you were talking about the fact that the shiny object syndrome and how people can have 10, 20, 30, 50, which is unimaginable to me. Because, I annoy myself now on my phone with how many apps I have there and how many pages I have to scroll. And it's like, "Why do I have these things there if I'm never using them?" So, I think that that's another good one in that first point that you spoke about with the legacy systems is maybe going back doing an assessment of what your inventory is? Where's their overlap? What's outdated? What's redundant? What no longer works? What doesn't have MFA capability? It needs to just go. So maybe it's time to prune.
Kurt Hagerman:
And start looking, modernizing your estate to be able to take advantage of the latest technology advances that can help you more easily secure your environment. And I think to the shiny object kind of a thing, the security industry itself, the product industry hasn't done us any favors. They're always coming out with the next best thing and next best thing. I remember when the payment card industry first introduced their data security standard, I went to RSA that same year, and literally every booth on the floor had some talk about how they helped you with your PCI compliance.
Stephanie Butler:
Oh my God.
Kurt Hagerman:
And so, when you're sitting in the CISO's chair, you're effectively being paid for silence. They don't want to hear from you. Because if they don't hear from you, that's good news. That's nothing has gone wrong.
Stephanie Butler:
Nothing's gone wrong.
Kurt Hagerman:
So if you're a great CISO and you do your job and there's no breaches, but the threat actors, the threat landscape continues to change and you need to continue to change and evolve. So what a lot of CISOs face is, not increases in budget, but decreases in budgets. Because we don't want to do that. And so the other thing that's happening is that these security companies are marketing to the executives, the CFOs, the CEOs, who now have skin in the game from a lot of these recent security mandates, where they could actually face personal liability or potentially even criminal liability. And so they're marketing. And so these guys say, "Well, let's go buy this. Let's go buy this. Let's go buy this."
And oftentimes these products are forced on the security organization and without any analysis to say, "Gee, we already have the risks that these tools covered. We already have that. We have processes and procedures in place that work. I don't need another tool. Please don't spend the money on that. Let me have the money to do a better job at vulnerability management or to make sure that I've got MFA on all the data that I need to protect."
Stephanie Butler:
Just following up on something you had mentioned that I also think is an issue is the ransomware. You had mentioned that earlier. So how do you advise payers to prepare for ransomware threats? We're talking about threats out there.
Kurt Hagerman:
I think first they have to recognize that they've probably already been breached. You have to come at it from the standpoint of, "It's not if I've get breached, it's when, and it's more often than not, when do I find out that I've been breached?"
Stephanie Butler:
That's scary.
Kurt Hagerman:
And so the preparedness really is, obviously you got to take care to do the basics. You got to be able to do defense in depth. You got to be able to do the best job you can to keep people out. You also have to do a very good job of monitoring so you have an understanding of what's happening within your environment. But where we're seeing people focus now is on recovery. So in most cases, people think about DR as well. "I'm good, because I've got another copy of my data somewhere else." The challenge is DR, was designed to protect against failures, hardware failures, software failures, fiber cuts, network outages. And so what you're doing is you're replicating data from site A to site B, oftentimes in near real time.
Well, if an attacker comes in and compromises the data in site A and you're replicating it to site B, you have garbage now in both places. So it's a different backup strategy where you have to take backups and push them into an isolated environment, where then you can test that data to ensure that it's actually still usable and hasn't been compromised. And then saving that, having that data stored in a isolated environment where it's not the same credentials that can be used to access it, that are used to access your normal environment. It's isolated from a network perspective so that someone does compromise your production environment. It's much more difficult, if not impossible for them to work laterally and get into this other environment. And then most importantly, when you start talking about payers and some of these very large payers, they have terabytes of data. So even if they have these backups in an isolated location and they get hit their production, it's going to take them potentially weeks to actually restore that data to a new environment.
They have to rebuild a new environment, and then they have... It takes time to push data over a wire to restore. So we have a program where we're recommending that they have effectively what we call a safe restore environment, where they're incrementally restoring the data that they've already tested and know is good into an environment that can be through automation, spun up into a full production environment very quickly. So they're not spending the money on an exact duplicate, but all of the pieces are there. So that when they get hit in their production environment, they can be up and running in hours or maybe a day or two as opposed to weeks or months.
Stephanie Butler:
Totally.
Kurt Hagerman:
And so that's where we're recommending that people take that kind of an approach. So it's a living cycle of backing up the data in an isolated area, testing it, ensuring it's good, and then restoring that data in an incremental fashion, so that they have an environment that's ready to go in the event that they get hit.
Stephanie Butler:
Again, it's something that sounds like, "Why wouldn't I have not thought of that?" But until you said it, I didn't.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
It's funny too, because we talk a lot about people process technology. And in the people part in healthcare, and I'll just call it out, security is something that is absolutely necessary. And yes, we train to it. And yes, we do the annual, quarterly or whatever it is, update mandatory training, et cetera. In practice though, sometimes we will do crappy passwords. Like the one, one, one, one, one, one. Or we'll rotate what dog or we'll do the password and then we'll take a picture of it, leave it on our phone or write it down somewhere.
Stephanie Butler:
I do that.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
I worked at a little hospital and it was amazing. They gave out candy bars. If you put in, when they updated the software, if you put in a password that had more than 16 characters, if you hit 20 or more, you got two. And I did it. It was something that was very hard to remember, but I did it. How do we... And this is for you, Kurt. And I apologize, Stephan.
Stephanie Butler:
No, go ahead.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
But I'm curious, the conversations you're having with especially the provider side, going through all of this to the payer, how do you get the people to say, "Yes, this matters", and comply with all of these things? Because most of the times we just want to get to the day, do what we have to do and go home.
Kurt Hagerman:
It's really a cultural shift that has to happen and everybody has to understand the importance of it. And I think the interesting thing is, most of the people that work in these healthcare organizations have also been subject to the breaches, and they're the ones that are getting the letters and the experience accounts. So everybody, you have to have a culture that says, "Hey, look. If you see something, say something. Be mindful about it." The phishing techniques are getting much more sophisticated. So it's getting harder to decipher whether this is a legitimate email or not. And everybody's always in such a hurry that that's when the mistakes happen. So it's like, if you get an email that sounds a little weird, take a minute and take your time to do that. But the other thing to get to the 20 character password thing, is that's why people are moving to passwordless security
Because, if you have to remember 10, 20 character passwords, you are going to write them down or the proliferation of password apps, password vaults have happened, but even those have been hit. And so those providers get hit as well, so that's not a perfect solution. So when you get to the point where you can do passwordless authentication via some sort of biometrics, whether it's a fingerprint, or most likely it's not a retinal scan, but it's a facial scan now because the technology in the iPhones, the Androids now, Windows Hello, that exists and it's very good. It works very well.
Stephanie Butler:
But also a way that it's easier for you.
Kurt Hagerman:
I don't have to do all the things.
Stephanie Butler:
They just have to look at the camera as opposed to figure out [inaudible 00:15:12].
Kurt Hagerman:
And in some cases, like what we've done in our journey at Oracle to move to passwordless is, we use that and then there's a second factor and they push an alert to another device. You have your phone and you just have to click allow. And then you're in
Stephanie Butler:
And you're in. I would do that.
Kurt Hagerman:
And so it has reduced the friction for us to get to the data that we need, just to operate our company, let alone in the healthcare space.
Stephanie Butler:
Absolutely.
Kurt Hagerman:
Where time is money and time is criticality.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
[inaudible 00:15:45] brushes up against customer accounts. I think that that is something that we have to do. Where we sit in the industry at Oracle, we have to do that. We are trusted with, I don't know how many, what comes after terabytes? See, I don't code. But it's like a gigabytes, whatever.
Kurt Hagerman:
Petabytes.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Petabytes. There we go. So we got a gazillion petabytes, probably update...
Kurt Hagerman:
Then it's just a crap ton of data.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
There you go. So we got that. We got the crap ton part. But with that responsibility and the 24x7, 365 global presence that we have, not having that level of security and that level of respect for the data, and how we access it, would be wrong. And I am thankful for us having that talk about the people part because there are times when you go in and you start talking with customers, and it's hard to say and put into words how fragile the systems are. We can't be going on Facebook at work. We can't be answering our personal email at work. I don't know how many cure eggs and Yetis I've won on my personal account. But if you're going in there, you're risking imploding the system with some crap from somewhere else. And now they're running through your system like that virus. They're all over. And it's just a matter of time before they flip the switch and it's gone. There's a commercial out with the lady who put her cat's name in there and all of a sudden all the alarms go off. I think it's a beautiful commercial.
Stephanie Butler:
I want to shift gears a little bit, because we were talking about technology and technology can be great, but it can also be difficult. But I want to think about some of the real advantages that we could have in some of the new technologies. So I want to ask you, Michelle, how do you see advancements in healthcare technology like AI, machine learning? How can they directly contribute to the efficiency and quality of patient care?
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
How many hours do we have? I'm serious. Because it could be hours. I think truth be told, it's across the system. It's everything from walking in the front door and making registration process seamless. I recently went in for my annual, and I came out and the doc told me two things I needed to do. One was schedule my MAMO, the other was make certain that I got my lab tests done. I called and I scheduled, and I get the next day my write-up and it says, I have three lab appointments, one on the day that I was there, which it wasn't true. One on the 18th, one on the 19th, and no MAMO. So even just making that something whereby the person who's helping me on the phone has easy capabilities of scheduling, those are even better yet. Put it in my portal so I can do it because I know what my calendar is, they know what their availability is, let's just do that. I think that would've been amazing. I would've gotten it right. I wouldn't be upset and Edna wouldn't be so apologetic when I called her back.
After that, we talk a lot about the documentation and we've done, I think so, so much for documentation. I think we need to step back from that and think about instead, what are the processes that take the providers, the patients, the nurses, the... I'm sorry, not the patients, but the nurses, the PAs, the NPs, all of us away from the bedside and away from care, and pull us into paper. Like referral management is one. More than 50% of referral orders that go out, never end in an appointment. Which is tragic. That means that somebody else who could have taken advantage of that is missing it.
After that, I also think about things like prior authorization. It is a Herculean task sometimes to go back through that chart to get it right for that provider with that payer, for that patient to get that done the first time right. Going back and doing that chart review is laborious and sometimes it's almost trying to find that needle in a haystack that yields the yes. We need to make that process come off of paper and we need to make it smarter. Would it be great? I think it would be phenomenal if we could know, "Okay. I love Edna. I don't know why, but Edna's my patient. She has these problems, she has this type of insurance. I as her provider, I'm filling out this thing for her prior auth." Before I sign it, it would be phenomenal if it said, "She has ABC insurance. They need these additional three items. Before you sign it, do this." And you won't have to go back through this chart again and delay the process.
Patient gets the referral, patient gets the care, the cycle continues. And on the payer side, they don't have to go and say, "Ooh, we can't do that because you missed this." And that roundabout stops. Patient care, better outcomes, patient doesn't get upset and get lost to the system and god forbid, end up having a change to their life and their livelihood, compromised because now they're ill. The other one is, first-time claims right rate. I have lost track of how many times my poor information department has come back and said, "You know Dr. Flemmings, we need to have this or it needs to be changed to that." Getting that process right the first time would be fantastic. Not that I want to disemploy my HIM department, but I think they could be doing other things. They could be maybe doing things that contribute to performance improvement, quality improvement, those sorts of things.
Maybe helping us to make certain that our credentials are right or what are the next things that we need to get for our credentialing and our accreditation at the hospital, those sorts of stuff. But can we take all of those processes off of paper? And then on my patient side, it should be easier for me and as much information and inside information and education as I have in healthcare, sometimes opening the envelope, it's like the red pill and the blue pill. I don't know which one I have to pay and which one I don't.
It would be great if those things were no longer on paper. Maybe it was in my portal. And it just said, "For this you owe." And it showed, and I could pay right there. Making it less friction. Because right now there are folks, and we were talking about this, that sometimes you're actually getting money back and you're just annoyed because it's another envelope and it's another thing from a payer and you toss it and it's like, "Oops, your $500 just went in the crap." So maybe what they could do is it could be easier and put in there, and I'm happy to work with anybody who wants to do that. Because being the patient, being the provider, being on the tech side, I see it from all sides.
I think that would be phenomenal. And AI can help. Absolutely. And then also, while I still have a little bit, the analytics. We need to start sucking that data through the machine and the compute and starting doing stuff with those terabytes. How can we connect the information that sits in claims with what's in these longitudinal records? And what's over here at this health agency? And oh, by the way, what the health department knows to maybe prevent this little kid at age two from becoming a lifelong asthmatic who can't do these things. Or prevent this little kid who's a diabetic from eventually getting heart disease or losing a limb or losing their sight. Even worse. How can we now take the data and the capabilities that we have to run the analytics and the genomics and get these things done so we drive the better outcomes that we're all sitting here trying to achieve.
Stephanie Butler:
So we have this rapid evolution of digital tools. What emerging technologies do you think leaders should prioritize to enhance patient? You're talking about a lot of things.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Oh, totally.
Stephanie Butler:
To enhance patient engagement, outcomes, and then how could they be integrated effectively into the systems?
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Totally.
Stephanie Butler:
Priority is key. There's a lot of stuff out there.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Totally. Everybody's concerned that patients are dissatisfied. I'm not so much concerned about the dissatisfaction. What I'm concerned about is that they're lost. They're lost in the data. They don't understand, maybe we're not talking to them in their preferred language or at a level in that language that they can understand. We talk a lot about meeting them where they are, and I still think we're missing the point. So, I would love us to concentrate more on capturing the information in a manner that suits that patient as an individual and recognizes the sanctity of that relationship with them. They're honoring us with their trust. And with that trust, we owe back to them what they can look at, they can understand, they can discuss with their family and say yes or no, or maybe even, just have it as a consider. "This is what I need, want and will do in order to get what I know is for me. My version of my best life."
I think that's vitally important when you're talking patient engagement. And I know that a lot of payers are trying to figure out, "How do we grow our membership?" That's simple part of making it less friction, honoring the security of the data, and also honoring them with the tools to help make the right decisions and explaining to them in a language that they understand why this is important, I think would matter a huge amount. And that would be something that would differentiate you for recognizing me, not just as a member with a number, but me as a member who's a patient. And we have a partnership going here. I think that would be amazing.
Kurt Hagerman:
And I think if you can streamline a lot of those processes, right now when you go to the doctor, I mean they're having a hard time. We moved three years ago, a little North of Seattle, and I could not find a primary care doctor. They did not have enough physicians up there and they can't keep up with the growth. Now I've found a clinic, but the other piece of it is, the information that you get is oftentimes effectively indecipherable. You have a test and they send you a test result. And even blood work, they give you all these numbers and all these things. And unless you are interested enough to go look them up to say, "Well, what does this actually mean?" And then even that time, half the time you're getting it wrong, because it's not a single number. It's a combination-
Stephanie Butler:
Of the numbers.
Kurt Hagerman:
... of three of the numbers that your doctor knows. So being able to leverage some of that technology to be able to create more plain spoken results to patients to say, "
Stephanie ButlerDr. Michelle FlemmingsStephanie ButlerDr. Michelle Flemmings:
So that pay viders space, I think that starting and making that patient engagement better, meaningful, more attainable, more accessible, would be great. In the provider space, I think we've gone through a whole bunch of stuff, and I have a lot of double-edged sword problems with clinical decision support. We talk about it a lot. And for me, what I want it to do is, I want it to make certain that I have the information that I need. I don't want it to disrupt me. And I also want to make certain that we always keep that human in healthcare. Because once you remove me as the decision maker, now the machine's making decisions and that's no good.
Stephanie Butler:
Right. That's true.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
And then on the other side of it all, I do think that we need to work on examining how are we helping our workforce with the technology? A lot of times the tech is happening to them, not with them. And it needs to be something that instead of happening to them, an experience that is like, "Oh my goodness. No, please not again." Let's make it something that is a tool, an enhancer that elevates your work, that allows you to be freed up from the mundane and do that thing that needs to have that human mission critical decision-making done. I think that would be great.
Stephanie Butler:
I hate to say, but we are just about out of time here. This has been fantastic, but I have one last question. So I just want to get your quick answer to this, and then we'll see where we are next time we have this conversation. So in your opinion, what do you see as the biggest innovation or disruption taking place in the healthcare industry in the next five or 10 years? Kurt?
Kurt Hagerman:
I think it's probably going to be the proliferation and use of AI tools to do a lot of the things that Michelle's been talking about. I think that as AI matures and as people understand how to better use it and how to better train their models, that it could have a pretty significant impact on efficiency, driving down the cost in the healthcare industry, and increasing patient's ability to understand what's going on and have some control over their healthcare.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Love it. Totally. And I think in the training, you got to think of it like it's a kid. And I'm not a mom, I'm a great aunt. But when you have a kid, you have it and you have it in your arms and it's in a cradle and it's all protected. And then it goes, and maybe it goes to daycare and it gets the cooties, but then it goes off and it goes to preschool, and it learns the F-bomb. It's very much like AI. You got to nurture it, you got to protect it. You got to point it at what you think it needs to know to be a good AI, a good human being. Where I see the most innovation and where I really hope we end up going is, we compound on the omics. All of the omics. The genomics, et cetera.
And then we take that and we start getting predictive because we are very much on the cusp of being able to say, "This patient now, if we intervene here in this manner, we can prevent them from losing their sight. We can prevent them from ending up on dialysis. We can prevent them from having a heart attack." So, I want us to really devote the time and the energy to figuring out, how do we do that without completely invading people's privacy? Because if we can't get the security right, I don't want people messing with my omics.
Stephanie Butler:
I do like your vision of the future. This has been a fantastic conversation. Thank you, Kurt. Thank you Dr. Flemmings, and thank you to Oracle. This has been great and I'm looking forward to seeing what you guys are up to next.
Dr. Michelle Flemmings:
Thank you, Stephan. This has been fantastic.
Kurt Hagerman:
It's been really great.