UnitedHealth report: Reducing price variation for diagnostic tests could save billions

Stethoscope on top of five, ten, and twenty dollar bills.
A new study from UnitedHealth examines price variation. (Getty Images/PLG)

Consumers could have saved billions in 2017 if price variation for certain services was addressed, according to a new report. 

UnitedHealth Group issued an analysis that examined price variation for several common tests: MRIs, ultrasounds, CT scans, pathology tests, microscopic examinations, radioisotope scans and mammography exams. Wide price variation for these services is inflating healthcare costs, the report concludes. 

If prices for these services were adjusted to the lower end of the pricing range, in 2017 consumers could have saved $18.5 billion, a 49% decrease. 

Free Daily Newsletter

Like this story? Subscribe to FierceHealthcare!

The healthcare sector remains in flux as policy, regulation, technology and trends shape the market. FierceHealthcare subscribers rely on our suite of newsletters as their must-read source for the latest news, analysis and data impacting their world. Sign up today to get healthcare news and updates delivered to your inbox and read on the go.

For example, in 2017, prices for echocardiograms varied from $210 to $1,830. A significant number of patients paid toward the lower end, but more than half paid from $480 to the higher limit. 

RELATED: Hospitals aren’t the only ones with price variation. New research shows payers have price discrepancies, too 

Spending on the seven types of tests included in the study totaled more than $37 billion that year. So, these findings show that adjusting prices toward the lower end and reducing the wide variation could lead to significant cost savings. 

Continuing with the example of echocardiograms: If prices for such services were lowered across the board to the lower end of the spectrum at $390, consumers would have saved $970 million, according to the study. 

Under that model, spending on echocardiograms would decline from $1.7 billion to $760 million, according to the analysis. 

“Price variation leads to gross overspending for many consumers, even for common health care services such as diagnostic tests, which play an important role in the diagnosis, monitoring and treatment of disease,” the researchers wrote. 

RELATED: Report—Looking for affordable healthcare? Stay away from San Jose 

The greatest cost savings could be found for MRI services, according to the study. Lowering prices to the 40th percentile would lead to $4.6 billion in savings, a 47% decline. 

These changes could lead to $3.7 billion in savings on ultrasounds (a 50% decline), $3.1 billion in savings on CT scans (a 56% decrease) and $2.7 billion in savings on pathology tests (a 56% decline). 

Regional variation in healthcare pricing is not a new phenomenon. A recent study from the Health Care Cost Institute found prices in San Jose, California, for example, were 65% above the national average, while in other regions they were below the average. 

Suggested Articles

Applying industrial engineering principles to insurers' processes and systems would be a smart way to identify and make improvements.

Hospitals raised alarms over legislation aimed at tackling surprise billing voted out of committee on Wednesday saying the measure could result in higher…

CMS has signed off on Louisiana's plan to use a Netflix-style subscription model to pay for hepatitis C drugs in its Medicaid program.