Large employers playing more 'activist' role in healthcare costs, dialing back push to high-deductible plans

Health insurance form with wood pen, basic calculator, white piggy bank, and pile of coins
Employers have begun playing an increasingly "activist" role in curbing healthcare costs, a trend that is expected to accelerate next year, according to the latest survey from the National Business Group on Health. (Getty Images/michaelquirk)

Employers have begun playing an increasingly "activist" role in curbing healthcare costs, a trend that is expected to accelerate next year, according to the latest survey from the National Business Group on Health (NBGH). 

Nearly half of all companies polled for the annual Large Employers' Health Care Strategy and Plan Design Survey said that they are doubling down on driving delivery system changes, using narrow network delivery models such as accountable care organizations, direct contracting and high-performance networks to shift healthcare costs. Nearly 60% plan to use these strategies by 2021.

In a surprise shift, fewer employers (30%) plan to offer consumer-directed—or high-deductible—health plans as the only option for their employees compared to 39% in 2018. The survey results were based on responses from 170 large employers representing coverage of 19 million employees and their dependents conducted between May and June 2018.

Free Daily Newsletter

Like this story? Subscribe to FierceHealthcare!

The healthcare sector remains in flux as policy, regulation, technology and trends shape the market. FierceHealthcare subscribers rely on our suite of newsletters as their must-read source for the latest news, analysis and data impacting their world. Sign up today to get healthcare news and updates delivered to your inbox and read on the go.

Brian Marcotte, president and CEO of the NBGH said he believes the growing interest in consumer-directed health plans was driven in part by employer's concerns about the Affordable Care Act's Cadillac Tax to go into effect in 2018. But that tax has been delayed twice by Congress and isn't expected to go into effect until 2022.

"There's a view it may continue to be kicked down the road. So I think employers are relaxing from that perspective," Marcotte said.

But there may also be additional reasons, he said.

"Are we at a tipping point in terms of cost sharing? Although employers do contribute to health savings accounts, on average $500 for an individual and $1,000 for a family, high deductible plans are a challenge," he said. "We also have very low unemployment so is a war for talent playing a role in this as well?"

RELATED: National Business Group on Health issues new recommendations for pushing PBMs on opioids 

Recent moves by Congress to expand the flexibility of health savings accounts may be a factor in reversing that trend toward consumer-directed health plans in the future, Marcotte said. 

"Employers are very interested in adding more flexibility into these plans," Marcotte said. He pointed to what consumer health plans did to reboot plan design and the key role of health savings accounts in making them work.

"There's a lot of rigidity in what you can do and what you can't do if you have a health savings account," Marcotte said. "Building back in flexibility, employers would like to cover more value-based services and provide a higher level of coverage. Whether it's chronic condition management or preventative services or Centers of Excellence, there is a real opportunity to get back into design based on value."

RELATED: Survey: More workplaces are expanding definition of wellness programs

Overall, the survey of employers found that they project their healthcare benefit costs are expected to rise about 5% for the sixth year in a row, reaching $14,800 per employee in 2019 compared to the $14,099 employers project in costs per employee in 2018.

The survey also found: