Patient dumping issues need systematic look


At this point, you've heard frequently about the problem Los Angeles faces with "patient dumping," which takes place when hospitals discharge indigent patients and more or less kick them to the curb. 

Allegedly, several LA hospitals with otherwise decent reputations have engaged in this practice. Some have been caught leaving mentally-handicapped or severely ill patients to wander around the city's infamous Skid Row in the hopes somebody else--probably, the homeless mission there--would deal with the patient's problems from that point on.

Now, I've taken a potshot or two at LA's hospitals, but in reality, I'm betting they don't dump patients any more often than hospitals in any other big cities. Sadly, I've little doubt that homeless patients get discharged and kicked out of vans and taxis onto rough streets in New York, Dallas and Miami, too.

The thing is, just how widespread is this practice? I wish I could tell you. While I wanted to share statistics that would give us a better overview of the problem, I didn't find any. The best I could come up with in my web research was a report released by Public Citizen in 2001. Public Citizen's data, which consisted only of EMTALA violations taking place between 1997 and 1999, noted that violations had been confirmed for 527 hospitals in 46 states during that period.

However, if that many EMTALA violations are being confirmed, one can only imagine that the kind of patient dumping we've described is even more common. After all, to commit an EMTALA violation, it has to happen in your emergency department, and it probably was documented in some form. Dumping a poor, homeless, mentally-ill patient and sticking a homeless shelter with their care may barely show up.

All told, it seems to me that this class of patient dumping needs far more study, and once the subject is better understood, the industry needs to take aggressive steps to address the problem before it happens. While I commend the LA city attorney's office for attempting to solve the problem by censuring offenders, it's our job as industry participants to see if we can fix what's broke. Readers, do you have any thoughts on this (or relevant research to share)?  I'd love to hear from you. - Anne

Suggested Articles

The profit margins and management of Community Health Group raise questions about oversight of managed care insurers.

Financial experts are warning practices about the pitfalls of promoting medical credit cards to their patients.

A proposed rule issued by HHS on Tuesday would expand short-term coverage, a move Seema Verma said will have "virtually no impact" on ACA premiums.