ACOs are a success for Medicare, but not for many providers

The Dartmouth-Hitchcock accountable care organization (ACO) was a substantial money-saver for the Medicare program, but it turned out to bleed red ink for one of New England's most prominent hospital systems.

That is a dilemma that ACO operators and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) will likely have to work out in the coming years, according to a recent blog post in the journal Health Affairs.

The system's Pioneer ACO was a fiscal success for CMS but mostly a money loser for Dartmouth-Hitchcock, according to the blog post authors--all executives and physicians with Dartmouth-Hitchcock, which is headquartered in Lebanon, New Hampshire. 

The system received a shared savings incentive payment of $1 million in the first year of the ACO's operations, but received financial penalties of $1.4 million in year two and $3.6 million in year three.

The penalties were incurred despite the fact that Dartmouth-Hitchcock's patients had the sixth-lowest per capita cost of the 19 Pioneer ACOs that remained with the program.

Dartmouth-Hitchcock "reduced annual per-capita expenditures by 3.9 percent, generating a cost savings of about $16.0 million while maintaining high-quality care," but "care costs were higher than the target set by CMS, hence the penalty," according to the authors.

The article faulted in part CMS' methodology for target-setting, which focused more on higher utilizers of healthcare services but were impractical for relatively low users, such as Dartmouth-Hitchcock.

That is not an uncommon story for providers that are operating ACOs. Despite the programs saving Medicare some $411 million last year, fewer than 100 of the more than 350 participating providers received a bonus payment. 

Dartmouth Hitchcock pulled out of its ACO just last month, citing its inability to make a financial go of the arrangement. That has led some experts to fear that the current model for ACO payment arrangements may be unsustainable.

To learn more:
- read the Health Affairs blog post

Suggested Articles

Account reps from Epic have told customers that the medical records giant will not be pursuing further integrations with Google Cloud, CNBC reported.

Healthcare CEOs admit they thought they’d be farther along in the transition to value-based care than they are today, a new survey shows. 

An analysis found that spending on hospital shoppable services, the subject of a CMS transparency rule, are minimal.