FierceHealthcareFierceHealthITFierceHealthFinanceHospital Impact   FiercePharmaFierceBiotechFierceSarbox
About | Sample | Privacy

Trend: Hospitals deporting uninsured immigrants

Tools
Tags
uninsured patients
Rehab Facility
martin memorial hospital
Luis Jimenez
Insurance
Illegal Immigrants

When an American citizen with health insurance--either commercial or government-backed--is seriously injured or sick, hospitals receive meaningful reimbursement for their care, even if they don't get as much money they want. But when an uninsured illegal immigrant is seriously ill, hospitals may get nothing. And when the patient is ready for discharge, hospitals can seldom find a rehab facility or nursing home to provide follow-up care--which often means that the hospital, without an appropriate place for discharge, keeps patients for months or years as a ward. Nobody pays these million-dollar bills. That's the case, in part, because the government won't pay for care for illegal immigrants, temporary legal immigrants or legal residents with less than five years in the U.S.

Lately, in response to these financial pressures, it's become more common to send such patients back to their home country, with or without their consent. Some patient families and attorneys call this patient dumping, but hospitals say they're just doing what they must to preserve their financial viability. While the practice isn't tremendously common, it does seem to be widespread, according to observers. No statistics exist on how often this happens, but it does appear that hospitals that see high volumes of illegal immigrants a year may engage in dozens of repatriations. The practice is so common that at least one repatriation company, California's MexCare, has emerged to serve these patients and help hospitals rid themselves of their burdens.

Recently, a legal decision in the case of one traumatically-injured Guatemalan worker, Luis Jimenez, may have changed the landscape somewhat. Mr. Jimenez was shipped to Guatemala by Martin Memorial Hospital of Stuart, FL, despite having an attorney who argued that the hospital was duty-bound to pay for his rehabilitation if need be. Since then, a decision by an appellate court held that since the hospital had no evidence Jimenez would get adequate care in Guatemala, they hadn't met federal requirements for discharge. Attorneys believe this case could change the way such deportations are regarded legally.

To learn more about this trend:
- read this piece in The New York Times

Comments

Maybe we can get MexCare to go into the prisons and ship back the illegal alien criminals that comprise so much of the prison population. Could be very cost effective.

it's amazing we call ourselfs a country of law!

The NYTimes spin meister ("all the news that fits" the NYT political agenda) did not objectively report the facts: the correct term is illegal alien, not "uninsured immigrant." Finally, someone is taking action against the continuing hemorrhaging of billions of dollars to subsidize law breakers who should burden their own countries' socialist systems in the first instance rather than steal from the US taxpayers who are forced to support the welfare hospitals in this country.

I think it's a great policy. People don't seem to be aware of all the hospital closings across the US because they are stuck with patients without insurance and Federal Law states they have to care for them. What happens when we are down to a handful of hospitals before our government wakes up and realizes this is a major problem. We don't have the money to care for American citizens who are often kicked out and we should always care for our own first, Always...

Unbelievably common sense, no doubt some hateamerolewyeh whose parents were saved from the flames by mine will cripple the policy. Only in America.

Illegal Immigration & Health Care are two very difficult topics to address; especially when our government does nothing to deport the 20 million plus illegal aliens already here. I’m sure a Dr. and a nurse could care less of who they do and do not treat. But in the end, it’s about money and what is right! And if the hospitals can’t pay their bills; we as Americans suffer. And let’s focus on that word “illegal” while you’re thinking about everything associated with the current medical crisis? Hospitals are going broke and not getting paid and at the same time Americans are paying through the nose for Health Care and suffering the consequences of an exploding illegal immigration problem. So it’s a triple blow to our economy. Our health care system is over-taxed and understaffed and our government does nothing to remove the illegals already here “ILLEGALLY”. And to make matters worse, they do nothing to stem the flow of illegals who continue to flood into this nation. As human beings we naturally care about everyone around us. But lets restate the obvious, illegal’s are NOT Americans. Communities that don’t speak English are not American. Businesses that knowingly break the law and allow illegal’s to have jobs are Un-American! Living the American dream is hard enough for Americans as it is. We shouldn’t grant Health Care services to people who sneak across the border and we shouldn’t grant US citizenship to illegal aliens who have babies here. And we should definitely applaud hospitals that deport illegal aliens back to their country of orgin (BEFORE) providing medical care!

The biggest users of the American welfare system are american citizens. That's right I said it. I work wih American citizens who do NOTHING but eat sleep and shit and recieve free health care and a living wage as well (the so called disabled). This article is misinformed and racist to boot all illegals are not Mexican. Some are actually European or Canadian. The US has a big problem whith it's health care system and scapegoating immigrants is not a solution.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about formatting options

What is 22 + 3?
To combat spam, please solve the math question above.