McDonald Hopkins Files Federal Lawsuit Challenging Constitutionality of Illinois Statute: Hospital-Based Physicians Seek to Inva

CHICAGO, July 12, 2011 /PRNewswire/ -- Hospital-based pathology groups and physicians in Illinois filed a federal lawsuit on June 24, 2011, seeking to invalidate, on constitutional grounds, Illinois legislation designed to shift the burden of absorbing certain patient-related costs from insurers to practitioners of only a few specifically-enumerated medical specialties.

The Statute: Illinois Public Act 96-1523

Illinois Public Act 96-1523, took effect June 1, 2011. It amended portions of the Illinois Insurance Act (changing 215 ILCS 5/356z.3 and adding 215 ILCS 5/356z.3a) in such a way as to fundamentally alter the relationships between certain physicians, their patients, and third-party payors such as insurers.

The statute prohibits an inexplicably singled-out group of out-of-network physician-providers from billing insured patients for anything other than the applicable deductible/co-pay that would apply if the provider were an in-network provider for that patient. According to the statute, the provider must seek any remaining amount due from the patient's insurer. In the event of a dispute as to the amount the insurer will pay, the statute mandates binding arbitration at the election of either the insurer or the physician. By its terms, the statute applies to only those physicians or other providers who provide radiology, anesthesiology, pathology, neonatology, or emergency department services to insureds, beneficiaries, or enrollees in a participating facility or participating ambulatory surgical treatment center.

Click below to read the full McDonald Hopkins Healthcare Litigation Alert:

McDonald Hopkins Law Firm Alert; McDonald Hopkins files federal lawsuit challenging constitutionality of Illinois statute

For more information, please contact:
Steven M. Harris
[email protected]

Anne Owings Ford
[email protected]

About McDonald Hopkins

McDonald Hopkins is a business advisory and advocacy law firm with offices in Chicago, Cleveland, Columbus, Detroit, Miami, and West Palm Beach. The firm's comprehensive legal services are provided by teams of specialized attorneys and professionals in areas such as business law, litigation, business restructuring and bankruptcy, estate planning, government affairs, healthcare, intellectual property, labor and employment, and mergers and acquisitions. The president of McDonald Hopkins is Carl J. Grassi. For more information about McDonald Hopkins, visit

Deborah W. Kelm
McDonald Hopkins LLC
600 Superior Avenue, East, Suite 2100
Cleveland, Oh 44114
Phone: 216.348.5733
Email: [email protected]

SOURCE McDonald Hopkins