GAO: Hospitals with low quality scores still received bonuses under value-based purchasing program

CMS must take steps to ensure lower quality hospitals don't qualify for bonuses under the value-based purchasing program, according to a new GAO report.

Although the government’s value-based purchasing program is meant to reward hospitals that provide high-quality care at a lower cost, a new report finds that some hospitals with low quality scores still received bonuses because they had high efficiency scores.

The Hospital Value-based Purchasing Program, established by the Affordable Care Act, creates financial incentives for hospitals that improve quality of care and efficiency.  A Government Accountability Office report (PDF) questions the methodology that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services uses to determine bonuses and penalties because a review of the program during 2013 through 2017 revealed that some hospitals with high efficiency scores received bonuses despite having relatively low quality scores.

RELATED: Hospital value-based purchasing could still work with the right redesign


Driving Engagement in an Evolving Healthcare Ecosystem

Deep-dive into evolving consumer expectations in healthcare today and how leading providers are shaping their infrastructure to connect with patients through virtual care.

Safety-net hospitals, which have a high-proportion of low-income patients, generally scored lower in quality compared to all participating hospitals, the report found. But small and rural urban hospitals with 100 or fewer acute care beds scored higher on efficiency compared to all hospitals. In four out of the five years of the analysis, small rural and small urban hospitals were more likely to receive a bonus compared to all participating hospitals but safety-net hospitals were more likely to receive a penalty.

Furthermore, the report found that the efficiency score had a greater effect on the total performance score among hospitals that were missing one or more quality scores. The CMS methodology compensated for these missing scores by increasing the weights of all of the non-missing scores. As a result, hospitals with missing scores were more likely to receive bonuses than hospital with complete scores.

RELATED: 3 traits of good value-based payment programs

While a majority of all hospitals received a bonus or a penalty of less than 0.5% each year, the percentage of hospitals receiving a bonus greater than 0.5% increased from 4% to 29% from fiscal year 2013 to 2017. Most hospitals had a bonus or penalty of less than $100,000 in 2017.

Attribution/Copyrights: GAO

To make sure lower-quality hospitals don’t receive bonuses going forward, the GAO recommended that CMS revise its methodology used to calculate total performance scores, as well as its method for announcing for missing quality scores. The report noted that the Department of Health and Human Services indicated it would consider revising the two methodologies.

Suggested Articles

CMS finalized a hospital payment rule that includes cuts to 340B payments and changes to the calculation of hospital star ratings.

When identifying improperly billed services, healthcare payers recognize that clinical claim reviews are an essential tool in their arsenal.

Operation Warp Speed plans to vaccinate 100 million people by the end of February for COVID-19 as approval of the first vaccine approaches.