Michigan mulls new $160M proton beam cancer centers

Abby Christopher — Tue, 24 Jun 2008 13:23:42 -0400

While some communities wonder if they can afford to build just one proton beam cancer center, providers have proposed roughly five such centers in Michigan. Final rulings on state certificate of need applications later this year will determine just how many centers may be approved.

Two rival providers--William Beaumont Hospitals and a cancer treatment consortium established by the University of Michigan--originally planned to jointly fund a single center and applied for a certificate of need to get state approval of the plan. Last week, Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm changed all that when she vetoed the now former partners' Certificate of Need application that had already won approval from the Michigan CON Commission. In her veto letter to the commission, Granholm stated that a single collaborative approach could violate antitrust laws under the federal Sherman Act and that the U.S. Department of Justice had raised similar concerns.

Each of the former partners plans to re-apply for a separate certificate of need approval. In fact, Beaumont Hospitals has already re-applied, having teamed with Indiana-based ProCure Treatment Centers to build its new for-profit proton beam cancer center. The University of Michigan Health Center's proton beam consortium has only filed a letter of intent, and plans to make a presentation to the state to make its case for the center in early September. The state is expected to rule on the Beaumont application by July 1. Other providers have also submitted applications that the state is expected to rule on by the end of July and the end of September.

State business and labor leaders worry that two or more multi-million dollar cancer treatment centers could drive up health care costs for employers and individuals. Many oncologists, cancer centers, carriers and policymakers around the country also are evaluating the pros and cons of making such high-ticket investments. Proton beam therapy is a relatively new alternative to aggressive cancer treatments such as chemotherapy and more established uses of radiation. Each facility can cost as much as $200 million.

For more information:
- check out the article at Crain's Detroit Business

MI sets strict limits on building costly cancer centers

Thu, 01 May 2008 06:59:57 -0400

Working to avoid a costly healthcare "arms race," a commission in Michigan has ruled that it will allow the construction of only one costly proton beam therapy center for cancer treatment. It's ordering the state's hospitals collaborate on a single center, rather than attempting to each raise the $100 million or more needed to build proton beam centers, the newest form of radiation treatment for cancer. Proton therapy, which uses nuclear particle accelerators to deliver radiation, are more precise than X-rays, but critics say that their advantage over X-rays hasn't yet been proved. Some observers suggest that hospitals are opting to build them largely because such a center adds to their prestige.

Prior to the announcement, Michigan healthcare system Beaumont Hospitals had planned to build its own $159 million proton therapy center in collaboration with ProCure Treatment Centers. After the announcement by Beaumont, other hospitals submitted their own proposals for such a center. Now, they'll have to work together. The commission is demanding a business plan from at least five hospitals, which would have to contribute a collective $13 million.

To learn more about Michigan's plans:
- read this article from The New York Times

Related Articles:
CT scan usage climbing, raising radiation fears
PET scan rates rising dramatically